Here is my latest analysis (Sunday evening) on CNN regarding Trump’s options to end the Iran war. I have a longer list of more detailed options, but I boiled it down to three. None are great. It ends with a question about how Presidents receive information to make such decisions.
Let me expand on that a bit about how Presidents are informed here. Presidents have always relied on many sources of information when faced with such a consequential decision as whether to bomb another country, as one would expect. These would include:
- President-chaired National Security Council meetings of his relevant cabinet leadership, which are informed by a series of policy meetings at multiple lower levels; these policy meetings generate ideas informed by intelligence/military/State Dept/Treasury/etc. expertise.
- Separate briefings from the Intelligence Community (PDB briefer/experts/leaders), Military leadership, Economic/energy leadership, etc. Lawyers.
- Input from foreign leaders (partners and allies)
- Input from other more trusted advisers and friends (WH inner circle, first lady, Congressional leaders, etc)
What is different now:
- There are few, if any, policy meetings beyond those chaired by the President. Sometimes the key people are not included; for example, Energy Secretary Wright and Treasury Secretary Bessent were not in the loop one day before US strikes on Iran on Feb. 28. There is no formal process that ensures a range of insights informed by experts across the US national security apparatus are debated, synthesized, and ranked.
- Intelligence briefings appear to be less frequent; separate briefings by the CIA Director do continue, although I find it less likely that experts are included.
- President Trump summed up his approach and the level of open consultation and debate in a Fox News interview in March, “I let them speak their mind, and they do. And we have some differences, but they, they never end up being much. I convince them all to, let’s do it my way.” In other words, his decisions are his own, and based mainly on his gut instincts. It is unlikely this modus operandi will change.